Living Potency

In a number of my bits of writing on pornography (all of which are now collected in A Theological Engagement with Pornography), I made much of the prioritisation of two concepts used in the metaphysical tradition of Aristotle and Aquinas. These are potential or potency (the way a thing could be) on the one hand, and actuality and act (the state of a thing as it presently is) on the other. 

In those pieces of writing, I drew heavily on John Milbank’s Beyond Secular Order, in which he spoke about a reversal of the medieval priority of act over potency. You could say that the beginning of Milbank’s modern genealogy lies in the priority of potency over act, such that one looks at one’s potential as the defining characteristic of a thing over what a thing actually is. As I argued in my article “Pornography and Christology”, it was precisely this reversal that underwrote a cultural imperative to depart from what is to what can be, as a way to metaphysically underwrite a cultural drive to look for endless novelty (which in turn defined the pattern of porn consumption).

In focusing on this thread, I may have given the impression that potency in and of itself is a negative category, given that its prioritisation came with the imperative to take leave of the concrete circumstances of what is presently…present. If I did give that impression, I do apologise.

What became apparent as I read further is that the problem lay not with potency per se, but with potency read in isolation of act. To put it more constructively, potency is an indispensable metaphysical category that must be read in conjunction with act.

While the importance of act might be self-explanatory (it is the category that underwrite what presently is, after all), I failed in those writings to to underscore the importance of potency. For if potency in isolation of act causes us to take leave of present reality, act in isolation of potency would cause us to become static. Put another way, it is potency that orients and moves everything towards its telos, its fulfilment; and it is potency that is the underlying principle of life. Indeed, at the risk of falling into the temptation of simply overstating it, potency has become synonymous with life.

This is why there has been a now near-millenium long fascination with the priority of potency over act, entrenched in the various manifestations of post-modern culture, whether in its progressive futuristic or reactionary nostalgic social, cultural and political expressions. Both rely on the idea that the present is not where life is to be found, but to be found instead in the soon to be created or recreated future or past.

The New Mother Tongue

The New Mother Tongue